FIFA Club World Cup: FC Barcelona 4-0 Al Sadd: Match Review
Well then, is anybody surprised? Barcelona are through to the final of the FIFA Club World Cup in Japan after a routine 4-0 victory over Al Sadd. The Qatari side offered little resistance, and goals from Adriano (2), Seydou Keita and Maxwell ensured that the Blaugrana will face Santos on Sunday. However, the match will be remembered for the potentially season ending injury suffered by David Villa.
Pep Guardiola did not start with a full strength side, obviously with one eye on Sunday’s final, but prior to kickoff, everyone knew the result was a mere formality. Of course, I have the luxury of hindsight and if Al Sadd had won, I could have switched it round to say that we never really knew about the Qatari side, but being frank, I left my house this morning knowing that Barcelona were setting up a showdown with Santos.
This game was effectively pointless, although unlike some others, I like the premise of the competition itself, but there is a huge potential for disaster as we witnessed today. Al Sadd set out defensively, in every sense of the word. Often they had a flat-back four which was supplemented by another four defensive midfielders. They didn’t threaten on the counter and from the get-go it was clear that coach Jorge Fossati decided for damage limitation.
There was a hint of fortune about the first goal, but the build up play was decent. Andres Iniesta was pulling the strings in midfield, and he found Pedro in space on the left-wing, thanks mostly to the narrow defense. Pedro cut inside one challenge and tried to hang the ball up at the back post. His cross was sublime, but no-one was quite on the same wavelength so Al Sadd should have cleared it with ease.
Should.
For whatever reason, the defender decided to try and touch it back to his goalkeeper despite rules prohibiting the use of a backpass. This left Mohamed in a tough situation, and he couldn’t react quickly enough allowing Adriano to sneak in and touch the ball into the net. Worse of all for Al Sadd, this mistake was by Nadir Belhadj, who is at least their most famous defender, which often translates into the best...
Then came the incident. David Villa broke free of the defense, and tried to control a long ball over the top. In stretching for the ball, he enabled the two Al Sadd defenders to catch him up and this meant that he had to hold off two other players while stretching to try and control the still bouncing ball. Stretching with his left leg, he loses balance on his standing leg, mainly thanks to his momentum. Sparing the details, he lands on that left leg and the end result is that he fractured his tibia.
This means that Villa will be out for 4-6 months, and in the worst case this means that El Guaje misses the European Championships. However, there is also a possibility that he may return by the start of April. It all depends on the results of surgery and his post-op recovery. All that’s left to say is that we all wish David returns as soon as possible, with no ill-effects, and at least gets his chance to represent his national side in the summer.
Alexis Sanchez replaced the outgoing David Villa, and soon after Barcelona were celebrating a second goal. Again it was Adriano, this time he cut inside from the right to receive a pass before curling the ball into the bottom corner. That was the first half over, and it seemed awfully pointless for the teams to re-emerge given the circumstances.
Of course, this is football, and they did indeed reappear for the second half, although Al Sadd still could not muster the courage to go for broke. You might think that they had nothing to lose, but clearly they did as they stayed as defensive as ever. Barcelona were in control it was merely a question of how many they wanted to score. Lionel Messi was again the creator in this match, similar to his position in the Clasico and Keita was the benefit this time.
Messi slipped a ball through the middle of two defenders straight to the Malian who dinked the ball past the keeper in what must go down as a great finish by the midfielder. Often I berate Keita for his performances in holding midfield, but I remain a fan of the ex-Sevilla man when he is played in a normal central midfield role.
Maxwell rounded off the victory with his first of the season from a tight angle, but it was a completely pointless game, made even more frustrating by the number of injuries picked up in the process. Carles Puyol took a knock; Sanchez looked to injure himself as well, while we all know about Villa’s injury. Why can’t we just have a match between the Copa Libertadores winners and the Champions League winners from Europe?
Only one of the 10 finals have featured a club from outside of Europe and South America, and that was last season when TP Mazimbe reached the final, only to be brushed aside by Inter Milan. The prize money of $5 million will cover Villa’s wage during his time injured (assuming he is out for 24 weeks and earns €150,000 per week). What great news...
Man of the Match goes to Pedro as it always goes to Lionel Messi! Aside from that, Pedro was a constant threat on the left wing, which is just as well considering Villa’s injury. Onto Sunday and the highly anticipated final against Neymar’s Santos.
Animo Villa!
30 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Before 2005
it always was 1 match between South American and European champs, but it was even worse back then in terms of injuries. Like I mentioned in my earlier post, after several bad matches, Ajax refused to play. Maybe instead of 1 match between UEFA and Copa L winners, they’ll do UCL and EL winners against 2 top American teams, round robin, this may also take care of Euro Supercup
I like that idea
Porto were infinitely better than Al Sadd, and Penarol were too.
Manager on Barca Blaugranes
If you really want you can follow my random musings on Twitter
by Arron Duckling on Dec 15, 2011 5:57 PM CET up reply actions
Sid Lowe's writeup from the guardian
http://www.guardian.co.uk/football/blog/2011/dec/15/david-villa-injury-spain-barcelona
The same paper calls this tournament the “Blatter Platter”—I love it!! (Of course they call the CL Big Cup and the EL Big Vase, too)
Endavant Villarreal!!
by Allen Dodson on Dec 15, 2011 6:30 PM CET up reply actions
If he had been complaining about his shin ..
why did he keep on playing? shouldn’t Barca medical staff had done something about it?
Don't get me wrong
I like the tournament, but there is a huge potential for injury when a side like this faces such an advanced squad like Barca. Though I feel for Villa as a fellow human being, I am not overtly concerned by his injury for the squad
Manager on Barca Blaugranes
If you really want you can follow my random musings on Twitter
by Arron Duckling on Dec 15, 2011 7:39 PM CET up reply actions
Though I'll agree that Porto and Penarol are better
I find a format like that unfair where teams not from South America and Europe have NO chance to win a supposed world title. That they usually are not good enough to shouldn’t really matter. I’m taking this from the perspective of being a player, manager, or supporter of a team from Oceania, Asia, Africa, or North America. OK, I know we’re not probably good enough to beat Barcelona, but shouldn’t we at least get the chance? There is some romance to the idea that it’s an open competition… the smallest of teams from the smallest of nations may not win it, but they have a path to do it. To set it up from the get-go so that it is literally impossible for a team from a certain region to win defeats the purpose.
The competition is set up where it’s pretty hard for a team from say, Oceania to win it. Europe and South America are seeded into the semifinals… which is the only way to do it. You couldn’t very well seed them into the final, could you?
As far as injuries, I’m truly sorry for Villa but hey, it happens. It could have been a friendly, or practice, or hell, he could have fell down the stairs. Look at Afellay, he was hurt in practice, no? Those are actually “meaningless”
And if I read it correctly, this is an injury that has to do with repeated stress and not just one incident. Which makes me question why he started in a “meaningless” game. I suppose I know less than the Barca physios, much less actually, but it just makes me wonder.
by Luis Mazariegos on Dec 15, 2011 7:21 PM CET up reply actions
Rest of the World have their chances
Olympics, World Cup just name a few. This format was an idea of FIFA so they cash on, I just wonder of much compensation Barca will get for injured players? are they (FIFA) going to make a cheque for 5 mil? Also, what’s the price money here, or I should I say “revenue sharing”? FIFA is filthy reach and clubs have to pick up tab for player development, salaries, treatments etc
Prize money is $5 million
FIFA must make that through sponsors alone
Manager on Barca Blaugranes
If you really want you can follow my random musings on Twitter
by Arron Duckling on Dec 15, 2011 7:40 PM CET up reply actions
Insurance
they must have some kind of insurance to cover injuries. I remember a year ago Galaxy did not let Beckham play during winter break because Spurs apparently did not want to buy extra insurance, or not sufficient one at least
Those clubs can do something on their own and cash in instead of supporting corrupt organization
that's hardly the same thing
look at say a zlatan ibrahimovic or nemanja vidic… or george weah in his day… great players for their clubs who played for countries that failed to even make the world cup… if you’re a player from a small african nation, yet a star for a big african club, it’s hardly the same thing.
i can tell you that in many countries, supporters see this as a rare chance to maybe even shock the world… i have first hand knowledge, for example, about saprissa from costa rica… their fans were delighted and extremely proud of their finish a few years ago (3rd)
i’d bet my house that supporters of mazembe felt the same about their team’s climb to second place. and for many teams, their finish in some of these competitions will be their biggest achievement in decades, if not ever.
the world cup, and the olympics of all things, are completely different because they are not club competitions. imagine if there was a world championship and barcelona could not play in it, and the reasoning would be “well they can play for spain, brazil, or argentina in the world cup” as a cule would you say, “oh, nevermind then”? i doubt it.
i think perhaps a better solution would be to allow teams winners of second tier continental competitions in, and seed them one before their current seeding. thus, the UCL champions would play a semifinal and final instead of a super cup and intercontinental cup… but without dropping the global aspect. hmm that gave me an idea, i’ll post it. it might be stupid but what the hey…
by Luis Mazariegos on Dec 15, 2011 8:17 PM CET up reply actions
OK, hear me out
Playoff
OFC 2nd Place: Amicale
Host 2nd Place: Nagoya
Group Stage: 2 Groups. Best placed team from each group advances.
OFC CL: Auckland
Host: Kashiwa
CAF Confed Cup: MAS Fez
Playoff Winner
CONCACAF 2nd Place: Real Salt Lake
AFC 2nd Place: Pohang Steelers
Playoff: Group A Winner vs Group B Winner
2nd Group Stage: 2 Groups, 2 best placed teams advance
Europa League: Porto
CAF CL: Esperance
AFC CL: Al Sadd
Playoff Winner
CONCACAF CL: Monterrey
Copa Sudamericana: U de Chile
Semifinal
Group C winner
UEFA CL: Barcelona
Group D winner
Libertadores: Santos
Final:
Semifinal winner vs. Semifinal winner
Supercups would be absorbed into this, so you can hand out a trophy for the semifinal winners… thus preserving the “Sextuple”
Barcelona would play one fewer game (2 CWC games but no Supercup). Porto would play at most 4 CWC games, which would be more… but they would be getting access to a tournament they would normally be left out of. The only teams that would suffer would be all the other confederation winners, who would have to play more games to get as far. But I think they are happy to just compete
This is all of course, just a fantasy…
by Luis Mazariegos on Dec 15, 2011 8:29 PM CET up reply actions
I like it
I just think that it needs a little more refining. Al Sadd were awful, an few extra games to see what they can do such as a group would be a fine idea
Manager on Barca Blaugranes
If you really want you can follow my random musings on Twitter
by Arron Duckling on Dec 15, 2011 8:33 PM CET up reply actions
thanks
It just occurred to me you could cut the crap before the 2nd group stage, and just have the normal OFC vs host playoff to decide the sixth team. That’s probably better.
by Luis Mazariegos on Dec 15, 2011 8:36 PM CET up reply actions
The global aspect aspect is highly overrated
These other clubs will not improve their development playing a few exhibition games. compared to Europe and South America, Asian and African club football is a joke. TP Mazembe’s win last year doesn’t change that. The clubs get better by playing against each other in their own confederations and Champions League, but they will always be behind Europe. The Al Sadds of the world have no chance in hell of beating Barca, and so they decided to represent the pinnacle of Asian football with that bullshit. How does that help anyone except FIFA, which we all know is a corrupt money machine?
by Al Benson on Dec 15, 2011 10:19 PM CET via mobile up reply actions
yeah
The IFFHS ranks Al Sadd as the 204th best team in the world, and the 19th best from the AFC…
Manager on Barca Blaugranes
If you really want you can follow my random musings on Twitter
by Arron Duckling on Dec 16, 2011 9:07 AM CET up reply actions
It's a shame about David Villa's injury.
Also a shame that the transfer nonsense will read “RvP to Barca” nonstop until the end of January.
by Sabrina Dessipe on Dec 15, 2011 6:39 PM CET reply actions
I may go berserk if that happens
Manager on Barca Blaugranes
If you really want you can follow my random musings on Twitter
by Arron Duckling on Dec 15, 2011 7:34 PM CET up reply actions
The only good thing that might come out of this is..........
that Soldado finally gets a call-up to the national team,he truly deserves it.I just hope this injury doesn’t ruin Villa for the rest of his career.
yeah
Although I am excited for Llorente to get his chance in the national side
Manager on Barca Blaugranes
If you really want you can follow my random musings on Twitter
by Arron Duckling on Dec 15, 2011 7:34 PM CET up reply actions
I dont see any good come out of this...
Saldado deserves a spot I agree, Torres in my opinion is the one that does not deserve a place in that team.
Anyway this club world cup is a waste of time.
by meadow on Dec 16, 2011 12:18 AM CET via mobile up reply actions
RvP to Barca? Lol it'll never happen..Madrid however might give it a shot..
I think Barca will have some serious trouble with this injury.
As good as Cuenca is..im not convinced he can deliver when it matters..Pedro, Alexis and Messi are left but simply cannot afford injuries…
Look, i get the idea of the tournament..but fact is..a team like Barca simply cannot afford to fly 20 hrs..get a player injured for so long..they should have kept it in Abu Dhabi..
Follow me on Twitter @InderMethil
RvP to Real Madrid...I don't think so.
Follow me on twitter@PrixFixeOnline
Staff writer for Managing Madrid
by Timm Higgins on Dec 15, 2011 9:16 PM CET up reply actions
yeah
With you there
Manager on Barca Blaugranes
If you really want you can follow my random musings on Twitter
by Arron Duckling on Dec 16, 2011 9:08 AM CET up reply actions
Oh yea Madrid have callejon...forgot bout him..well pretty sure Barca wont go for persie
Follow me on Twitter @InderMethil
For all of you who voted Messi MOTM, GIVE me a break
He was a walking statistician for most of the match, with 1 assist.
Adriano scored 2 goals, Thiago assisted on 2 and Iniesta had a very good game
Unless hell frizzes over, he does not deserves to be MOTM, not this one at least!
Well i voted adriano i think but does it really matter? Lol
Follow me on Twitter @InderMethil
by Inder Methil on Dec 17, 2011 9:10 AM CET up reply actions

by 





















